The blog I have chosen to write about for my essay
is Big Questions Online. Picking a blog was very hard for me and I didn’t
really know what I was doing. Most blogs just talked about the latest news or
the juiciest scandal. But what caught my attention on Big Questions Online is
that the first thing I saw was the question “Why Should Scientists Care About
Religion?”. Seeing an article with that title completely blew me away. I became
hooked jumping from article to article. But what I really wanted to figure out
was if the blog was biased or not. Because obviously, everyone has their own
beliefs about religion and their own beliefs about science. I wondered if this
would be a blog that pushed you into believing one way by using rhetorical devices
and other concepts. As I began to read the article I was shocked. The author
states that he is a scientist and a Muslim which really shocked me. He tried to
convince others with his spiritual beliefs to look into modern science and vice
versa with his fellow scientist colleagues. The article wasn’t biased at all
and looked at each view in every perspective. The author Nidhal Guessoum states
“It may be obvious
that we cannot ignore science, with its methods and results. But it would also
be beneficial to humanity if science and scientists not only refrained from
trying to erase all that religion can provide and insisting on purely rational
behaviors but also gleaned some of the positive contributions that it can make
to humanity. There is more to the world than science can see. . .” I hope that
all the other articles on this blog look at any situation in the same way by
viewing all sides of the problem. It makes me question if maybe I’m blindsided
to a biased opinion or not. Or if others see something in a different way than I
do. Then I went to the discussion and saw others people’s arguments and
perspectives. This blog will be great to write my paper on since it deals with
so many discussions that cannot obviously have a right or wrong answer.
Blog Analysis Peer Review Workshop
ReplyDelete8/28/2013
Author: Brigid Kane Reader: Camille Ponseti
What blog is the author analyzing?
Big Questions Online
What point do you see the author making about that blog? Summarize it in your own words.
She really likes how the article has a very unbiased, open-minded view on something so controversial. She likes how the authors looks at the subject from all sides. Unlike most, the author of the article doesn't see science and religion as enemies.
What do you find most interesting about what the author’s saying about the blog?
I love the quote you pulled. It's a quote that religious and non-religious people alike can appreciate. I also like how she questions whether or not she is biased.
What suggestions can you give the author to help her/him develop her/his thesis?
I think you should focus on how the article(s) make you question bias and how much there is in the world about things that haven't been proven. Also maybe use the blog to find signs and ways of having an unbiased view.
What do you think is the most useful/interesting evidence the author is using from her/his chosen artifacts?
That quote is brilliant. It's a wonderful example of seeing the "rightness" to both sides instead of leaning left or right. Try to find more quotes that show that multiple sided view.
How could she/he develop more effective evidence from her/his artifacts?
Try to find more articles on controversial subjects and pull openminded quotes. (I'm really in love with that quote you pulled it's just great)
Great job, both of you! This is right on task!
ReplyDelete